Why 23andMe Says "Broadly South Asian" - And How to Get Real Indian Ancestry Results

You spent ₹10,000-20,000 on a 23andMe test, waited weeks for results, and opened your ancestry report expecting to learn something fascinating about your heritage. Instead, you got: "97.2% South Asian. 2.8% Broadly South Asian." Maybe, if you were lucky, a later update gave you "North Indian and South Pakistani" or "Bangladeshi and Northeast Indian." But for most Indian users, the experience is the same: vague categories that tell you nothing you did not already know.

You are not alone. This is the single most common complaint from Indian users of 23andMe, AncestryDNA, and MyHeritage. And the reason it happens is not a bug or a limitation of DNA testing technology. It is a reference panel problem, a fundamental design choice that makes global tests almost useless for the 1.4 billion people who live in the most genetically diverse country on Earth.

Short answer: 23andMe shows "Broadly South Asian" because its reference panel holds a few thousand Central and South Asian samples for a subcontinent of 4,635 anthropologically defined populations, so the algorithm cannot place your DNA much more precisely than "South Asian." You do not need a new test to fix it. You can upload your existing 23andMe (or AncestryDNA/MyHeritage) raw data file to Helixline from $25, and it is re-analysed against an India-specific panel to resolve your ancestry to the state and community level, including ANI/ASI/AASI ratios and deep haplogroups your original report never showed.

The Core Problem: 23andMe's own July 2024 announcement put its whole Central and South Asian reference panel at 2,696 samples, 2,164 of them its own customers, for a region in which India alone holds 4,635 anthropologically defined populations (Tamang and Thangaraj 2012). This is like mapping India from a couple of thousand GPS points: you get the rough outline, but no state boundaries, no cities, and no detail. Helixline's reference panel, by contrast, clusters South Asian populations into 140+ community groups within a global panel of 7,600+ samples, enabling state-level and community-level ancestry resolution.

Understanding the "Broadly South Asian" Problem

To understand why 23andMe fails Indians, you need to understand how ancestry estimation works at a technical level. Every DNA ancestry test follows the same basic process: compare your DNA against a reference panel of known populations, and calculate which populations your DNA most closely resembles.

How Reference Panels Work

A reference panel is a curated database of genomes from people whose ancestry is well-documented, typically going back at least three generations. When 23andMe says you are "42% British and Irish," they are comparing your DNA to genomes from people who have four grandparents all born in Britain or Ireland. The more reference samples you have from a specific population, the more confidently the algorithm can assign ancestry to that group.

Here is where the problem for Indians begins. 23andMe's own published region list divides the world very unevenly:

  • Europeans: separate groups for British, Irish, French, German, Italian, Greek and Scandinavian ancestry, among others
  • East Asians: separate groups for Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Filipino and Vietnamese ancestry, among others
  • Africans: separate groups across West, Central, East and Southern Africa
  • South Asians: seven populations in all, from a Central and South Asian panel of 2,696 samples

The disparity is staggering. Europe, with a population of about 450 million and relatively low genetic diversity (due to extensive historical gene flow between European populations), gets a group for almost every nationality. India, with 1.4 billion people and 4,635 anthropologically defined populations, shares seven groups with the whole of Central and South Asia, built on 2,696 samples.

Why India Is Uniquely Hard for Global Tests

India is not just another underrepresented region. It presents a unique challenge for ancestry algorithms because of three factors that make it fundamentally different from Europe or East Asia.

Extreme endogamy: Indian communities have married within the community since the ANI-ASI mixture that Moorjani et al. (2013) dated to between about 1,900 and 4,200 years ago. That has created hundreds of genetically distinct population clusters, 81 of them with founder events stronger than those in Ashkenazi Jews or Finns (Nakatsuka et al. 2017). A Nair from Kerala and a Jat from Haryana sit far apart on that spectrum. But where 23andMe can distinguish Spanish from Finnish with ease, because its European panel is dense, it cannot distinguish Nair from Jat because it lacks sufficient reference samples from either community.

The ANI-ASI cline: Indian genetic variation follows a primary north-south gradient called the ANI-ASI cline. Northern populations have more Ancestral North Indian (ANI) ancestry (related to Central Asian and Iranian populations), while southern populations have more Ancestral South Indian (ASI) ancestry (indigenous to the subcontinent). This cline is continuous, not categorical. Without a dense reference panel that samples communities along the entire gradient, an algorithm cannot determine where on the cline a person falls, so it defaults to "South Asian."

Multi-dimensional variation: Unlike European genetic variation, which is primarily captured by a single north-south/east-west gradient, Indian genetic variation is multi-dimensional. Beyond the ANI-ASI axis, there is an East Asian admixture gradient (highest in Northeast and Bengal), an Austro-Asiatic substrate (in central and eastern tribal populations), and extensive community-specific drift. Capturing this complexity requires a reference panel that is not just large but specifically designed for Indian genetic architecture.

23andMe's 2025 South Asian Update: Better, But Still Inadequate

23andMe has improved its South Asian reporting twice. In July 2024 the single "South Asian" category was replaced with seven Central and South Asian populations:

  1. North Indian and South Pakistani
  2. Central and Southern Indian
  3. Bangladeshi and Northeast Indian
  4. Gujarati Patel
  5. Kannadiga, Tamil, Telugu and Sri Lankan
  6. Central Asian
  7. Malayali

In January 2025 it added 44 finer genetic groups beneath them, named for regions such as the Bengal Basin and the Malwa Plains. Both were improvements. Users who previously saw only "100% South Asian" could now see, for example, "62% North Indian and South Pakistani, 23% Gujarati Patel, 15% Broadly South Asian." For users whose community was represented well enough to get a group of its own, this was meaningful new information.

Why Seven Populations Are Not Enough

But seven populations for nearly two billion people is still woefully inadequate, and the 44 new groups are regions, not communities. Consider what each covers:

23andMe Category Populations Lumped Together Approximate Population
North Indian and South Pakistani Punjabis, Rajputs, Jats, Khatris, Brahmins (UP/Bihar/MP), Sindhis, Marathis, Odias, Kashmiris, etc. ~600 million
Kannadiga, Tamil, Telugu and Sri Lankan Tamils, Telugus, Kannadigas, Sri Lankans, all castes and tribes within each ~240 million
Bangladeshi and Northeast Indian Bengalis (all castes), Assamese, Nagas, Mizos, Manipuris, Khasis, etc. ~250 million
Gujarati Patel Patels and Patidars; other Gujarati communities fall into the North Indian group ~70 million
Broadly South Asian Everyone the algorithm cannot confidently assign to the above categories Varies

Telling a Rajput from Udaipur that they are "North Indian and South Pakistani" provides almost no information. They already knew they were from North India. They wanted to know they are specifically Rajasthani with strong Marwari community affinity, where they sit on the steppe ancestry gradient, and whether their R1a-Z93 lineage links them to Bronze Age Central Asian migrations. That level of detail requires a reference panel with thousands of Indian communities, not seven broad populations.

The persistent "Broadly South Asian" category is particularly frustrating. For many Indian users, a large share of their ancestry is still returned as "Broadly South Asian" even after the 2025 update. This is the algorithm's way of saying "I know you are from South Asia, but I do not have enough reference data to be more specific." It is the genetic equivalent of a shrug.

What a Real Indian DNA Test Shows

To understand the gap between global and Indian-specific tests, let us look at what a typical Indian user receives from each service.

Typical 23andMe Result for an Indian User

  • 62.3% North Indian and South Pakistani
  • 18.7% Broadly South Asian
  • 12.1% Kannadiga, Tamil, Telugu and Sri Lankan
  • 4.2% Central Asian
  • 2.7% Unassigned

Total meaningful Indian ancestry detail: effectively zero beyond "you are mostly North Indian with some South Indian." The person already knew this from their family history.

Typical Helixline Result for the Same Person

  • Ancestry Composition: 34% Rajasthan (Marwari cluster), 22% Gujarat (Patel-adjacent), 18% Madhya Pradesh (Malwa region), 14% Uttar Pradesh (Awadhi cluster), 8% Maharashtra (Vidarbha), 4% other regions
  • Community Match: Highest affinity to Rajasthani Rajput communities (93% confidence), secondary affinity to Gujarati Vania communities (78% confidence)
  • ANI/ASI Breakdown: 68% ANI, 30% ASI, 2% East Asian-related
  • Paternal Haplogroup: R1a-Z93 > L657.1, the branch carrying 98.4% of Central and South Asian R1a (Underhill et al. 2015)
  • Maternal Haplogroup: U2, resolved to the branch and compared against South Asian reference lineages
  • Neanderthal DNA: 1.67% (higher than 72% of Indian users tested)
  • Migration Path: Steppe > Iranian Plateau > Indus Valley > Rajasthan > Gujarat (with estimated timeline)

The difference is not incremental. It is transformative. One result tells you nothing new. The other tells you a detailed story about who your ancestors were, where they lived, and how they moved across the subcontinent over thousands of years.

Get Real Indian Ancestry Results

See state-level ancestry, community matching across 140+ groups, and deep haplogroup analysis - designed for South Asian genetics.

Order Your Kit

The Technical Explanation: Why Resolution Matters

For readers who want to understand the technical underpinnings, here is why reference panel size directly determines ancestry resolution.

Principal Component Analysis and Clustering

Ancestry estimation algorithms use techniques like principal component analysis (PCA) and model-based clustering (ADMIXTURE) to assign your DNA to populations. In PCA, each genome is plotted in a high-dimensional space defined by genetic variation. Populations that are genetically similar cluster together. The algorithm assigns your ancestry based on which reference clusters your DNA falls closest to.

With seven Central and South Asian reference clusters, the algorithm can distinguish a Bengali from a Gujarati (these populations are genetically quite distant), but it cannot distinguish a Rajasthani Rajput from a Uttar Pradesh Thakur (these populations are genetically close and require dense reference sampling to separate). The result is that closely related but distinct populations get lumped into the same broad category.

With 140+ reference clusters (as in Helixline's panel), the algorithm has enough resolution to separate populations that differ by even small amounts of genetic drift. This is why Helixline can identify your ancestry at the community level while 23andMe can only manage broad regional categories.

The F-statistic Problem

Population geneticists use a metric called FST (fixation index) to measure genetic differentiation between populations. Reich et al. (2009) measured an average pairwise FST of 0.0109 across 19 Indian groups, against 0.0033 across the 23 European groups they compared it with. Indian populations are, on that measure, about three times as differentiated from each other as European populations are.

This means that a reference panel sized for European ancestry estimation is inadequate for Indian ancestry estimation, where neighbouring communities can be almost indistinguishable while groups at opposite ends of the cline are strongly separated. To achieve the same resolution in India that 23andMe achieves in Europe, you need proportionally far more reference samples, not fewer.

How to Get Better Results from Your Existing 23andMe Data

If you have already taken a 23andMe test and are disappointed with your South Asian results, there are several options to extract more value from your existing data.

Option 1: Upload Your Existing Raw Data to Helixline

Helixline's raw data upload feature lets you import your 23andMe (or AncestryDNA/MyHeritage) raw data file and reanalyze it against Helixline's Indian-specific reference panel: no new kit, no new saliva sample. You get state-level ancestry, community matching across 140+ groups, and ANI/ASI component analysis using the genotype data you already have, with results in days. Just upload your file at helixline.in/upload, starting from $25.

Important caveat: raw data uploads will not provide the full resolution of a native Helixline test. This is because 23andMe's genotyping chip is designed for European-relevant genetic variants and may not cover all the South Asian-specific variants that Helixline's chip captures. You will get significantly better results than 23andMe's own analysis, but for the best possible Indian ancestry detail, a fresh Helixline test is recommended.

Fix Your "Broadly South Asian" Result: from $25

Already tested with 23andMe? Upload your existing raw data file (no new kit needed), and get state-level Indian ancestry, 140+ community matching, and ANI/ASI/AASI breakdown.

Upload Your Raw Data

Option 2: Use Third-Party Analysis Tools

Several free and paid tools allow you to upload raw DNA data for additional analysis. GEDmatch provides admixture calculators (such as Harappa World and MDLP) that include South Asian-specific reference populations. These tools can give you a rough breakdown into components like "Baloch," "South Indian," "NE Euro," and "SE Asian," which are more informative than 23andMe's broad categories. However, these tools require significant genetic literacy to interpret correctly and can produce confusing or misleading results for non-experts.

Option 3: Order a Helixline Test

The most straightforward solution is to order a purpose-built Indian DNA test. Helixline's Origins kit at ₹7,499 provides the level of detail that Indian users expect and that global tests cannot deliver. If you have already spent ₹10,000-20,000 on a 23andMe test from India, spending ₹7,499 on a test that actually tells you something meaningful about your Indian heritage is a worthwhile investment.

Side-by-Side Comparison: What You Get for Your Money

Feature 23andMe (from India) Helixline Origins
Price (effective, from India) ₹10,000-20,000 ₹7,499
South Asian sub-regions 7 populations plus 44 geographic groups 28 states + 140+ communities
Community matching Not available 140+ Indian communities
ANI/ASI breakdown Not available Included
Indian-specific haplogroups Basic haplogroup only Detailed subclades with Indian context
Migration pathway Generic "South Asian" Detailed subcontinental migration
Ships to India No (requires forwarding) Yes, free two-way shipping
DNA Relatives matching Yes (large global database) Growing Indian database
Reference panel for Indians 2,696 Central and South Asian samples 140+ Indian community clusters

The one area where 23andMe retains a clear advantage is its DNA Relatives feature. With over 14 million customers, 23andMe has the world's largest genetic database for relative matching. If finding distant cousins is your primary goal, particularly in the diaspora, 23andMe's relative database is unmatched. Many Indian users choose to take both tests: 23andMe for the relative matching and Helixline for actual ancestry detail.

The NRI Perspective: Special Considerations for Indians Abroad

For Non-Resident Indians (NRIs) in the US, UK, Canada, Australia, or the Gulf, the situation has some nuances worth considering.

23andMe Is Easier to Access Abroad

If you live in a country where 23andMe ships directly, the logistical advantage is real. You order online, the kit arrives in days, you spit in the tube, a courier picks it up, and results arrive 2-3 weeks after it reaches the lab. There is no international shipping hassle. For this convenience, some NRIs are willing to accept the limited South Asian resolution.

But Ancestry Curiosity Runs Deeper for NRIs

Paradoxically, NRIs often have a deeper hunger for detailed ancestry information than Indians living in India. When you live in your ancestral homeland, surrounded by family and community, your identity is reinforced daily. When you live in Houston or London or Dubai, your Indian identity becomes more abstract, and the desire to understand it at a molecular level becomes more intense. Being told "you are South Asian" by 23andMe can feel almost insulting when you were hoping to discover the specific threads that connect you to your ancestral village.

Helixline ships internationally, making it accessible to the global Indian diaspora. For NRIs who have already tried 23andMe and been disappointed, Helixline offers the detail they were looking for in the first place.

Read next: Indian American DNA Ancestry: Save Your Data, Then Find Your Indian Roots.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does 23andMe say I am 100% South Asian with no breakdown?

23andMe's ancestry algorithm relies on a reference panel that, by its own July 2024 figure, holds 2,696 Central and South Asian samples for nearly two billion people. Without enough reference samples from different Indian regions and communities, the algorithm cannot distinguish between genetically distinct populations. Even after the seven populations of 2024 and the 44 regional groups of January 2025, many users still see a large "Broadly South Asian" percentage because the reference panel remains too sparse to confidently assign ancestry to specific categories. Indian-specific tests like Helixline resolve 140+ Indian community clusters, providing the resolution needed for meaningful results.

Did 23andMe improve South Asian results in their 2025 update?

Yes, twice. July 2024 replaced the single "South Asian" category with seven populations: North Indian and South Pakistani, Central and Southern Indian, Bangladeshi and Northeast Indian, Gujarati Patel, Kannadiga, Tamil, Telugu and Sri Lankan, Malayali, and Central Asian. January 2025 added 44 finer genetic groups beneath them. This was a notable improvement, particularly for communities with strong representation in 23andMe's customer base. However, seven populations for nearly two billion people remain extremely broad. "North Indian and South Pakistani" alone covers over 600 million people across dozens of states and thousands of communities. For most Indian users, the results are still too vague to be meaningful compared to tests with Indian-specific reference panels.

Can I upload my 23andMe data to Helixline for better Indian results?

Yes. Upload your 23andMe, AncestryDNA or MyHeritage raw data file at helixline.in/upload, from $25, and it is reanalysed against Helixline's Indian-specific reference panel. That gives state-level ancestry, community matching, and ANI/ASI analysis using your existing data. For the most comprehensive results, a fresh Helixline test is recommended, as Helixline's genotyping array is optimized for South Asian genetic variants that 23andMe's chip may not cover.

What does a real Indian DNA test show that 23andMe does not?

An Indian-specific test like Helixline provides ancestry composition at the state level (for example, 34% Rajasthan, 22% Gujarat, 18% Madhya Pradesh), community matching across 140+ Indian endogamous groups with confidence scores, ANI and ASI component percentages, detailed haplogroup analysis with Indian-specific subclade information and historical context, migration pathway mapping showing ancestral movements across the subcontinent, and Neanderthal/Denisovan ancestry calibrated for South Asian populations. A typical 23andMe result for the same person would say "62% North Indian and South Pakistani, 19% Broadly South Asian."

Is 23andMe worth it for Indians living abroad?

23andMe has some value for NRIs: its DNA Relatives feature with 14+ million customers is unmatched for finding distant cousins in the diaspora, and its health reports are well-validated with FDA approval for select conditions. However, for ancestry purposes, the results remain disappointingly vague for most Indians. Many NRIs take both tests: 23andMe for relative matching and health features, and Helixline for actual Indian ancestry detail. If you can only afford one test and your primary goal is understanding your Indian heritage, Helixline provides dramatically more value at a lower price point (₹7,499 against ₹10,000+ for a 23andMe kit landed in India).

Can I fix my 23andMe "Broadly South Asian" result?

Yes. The "Broadly South Asian" label is a limitation of 23andMe's reference panel, not of your DNA, your raw genotype data already contains the information needed for a far more specific breakdown. You can fix the result by uploading your existing 23andMe raw data file to Helixline at helixline.in/upload, where it is re-analysed against an India-specific reference panel. Most customers who saw only "Broadly South Asian" on 23andMe receive specific state-level and community-level ancestry from Helixline, starting from $25 (₹1,999).

Do I need a new test, or can I just upload my existing data?

You do not need a new test. If you have already tested with 23andMe, AncestryDNA, MyHeritage, or FamilyTreeDNA, you can simply download your raw data file from that service and upload it to Helixline: no new saliva sample, no kit, no shipping. The same 600,000+ SNP markers that produced your vague "Broadly South Asian" result are re-read against Helixline's South Asian panel to produce a detailed Indian ancestry report, usually within a few days. A fresh Helixline kit is only worth it if you want the highest possible resolution from a South Asian-optimised genotyping chip.

How detailed does Helixline get: state or community level?

Both. Where 23andMe stops at seven broad populations and 44 geographic regions, Helixline resolves your ancestry to the state level (for example, 34% Rajasthan, 22% Gujarat, 18% Madhya Pradesh) and matches you against 140+ Indian endogamous communities with confidence scores. It also reports ANI/ASI/AASI component ratios and deep Y-DNA and mtDNA haplogroup subclades with South Asian context, none of which appear in a 23andMe report. This community- and state-level detail is exactly what the "Broadly South Asian" label fails to provide.

Conclusion

The "Broadly South Asian" problem is not a flaw in DNA testing technology. It is a consequence of building tests for a European and American market and treating 1.4 billion Indians as an afterthought. With 2,696 reference samples for all of Central and South Asia, 23andMe still cannot tell Indian users much that is specific about their heritage.

The 2024 and 2025 updates improved matters from "useless" to "slightly informative," but seven populations and 44 regions cannot separate communities endogamous for thousands of years. If you are Indian and you want a DNA test that treats your ancestry with the same level of detail that European users have enjoyed for a decade, you need a test built specifically for Indian genetics.

Whether you are in India or part of the global diaspora, the era of settling for "Broadly South Asian" is over. Tests like Helixline now provide the state-level, community-level, and component-level detail that Indians have always deserved but never had access to before. Your DNA has a specific and fascinating story to tell. You just need the right test to read it.

For more on how DNA testing works for Indians, read our 2026 DNA test price comparison and our guide to understanding your Indian DNA results.

Done with "Broadly South Asian"?

Get state-level ancestry, 140+ community matching, and real haplogroup analysis built for Indian genetics.

Order Your DNA Kit

References

  1. Reich et al. (2009). Reconstructing Indian population history. Nature.
  2. Moorjani et al. (2013). Genetic Evidence for Recent Population Mixture in India. The American Journal of Human Genetics.
  3. Nakatsuka et al. (2017). The promise of discovering population-specific disease-associated genes in South Asia. Nature Genetics.
  4. Tamang and Thangaraj (2012). Genomic view on the peopling of India. Investigative Genetics.
  5. Underhill et al. (2015). The phylogenetic and geographic structure of Y-chromosome haplogroup R1a. European Journal of Human Genetics.
  6. Narasimhan et al. (2019). The formation of human populations in South and Central Asia. Science.
  7. 23andMe (8 July 2024). New Central and South Asian populations, and a reference panel of 2,696 samples. 23andMe Blog.
  8. 23andMe (30 January 2025). 44 new genetic groups for South Asia. 23andMe Blog.
Done with "Broadly South Asian"? Get state-level ancestry detail Order Kit - ₹7,499